Siesta Key isn’t just known for its white sand beaches—it’s also a food lover’s paradise.
This island has everything from fresh seafood to classic American comfort food.
This list covers the best restaurants in Siesta Key, including local favorites and top-rated eateries.
1. Made in Rome Organic Gelato
Looking for a way to cool off in Siesta Key? Made in Rome Organic Gelato is the perfect spot.
This casual counter-serve ice cream parlor specializes in handcrafted Italian gelato.
The shop’s simple interior focuses on the glass showcase, where you can choose from a variety of refreshing flavors.
If you’re craving something rich, the Cioccolato Fondente (Dark Chocolate) is a must-try.
Feeling adventurous? Go for the Pane, Burro e Marmellata (Bread, Butter, and Jam) for a unique twist.
2. Summer House Steak & Seafood
For an upscale dining experience, Summer House Steak & Seafood delivers high-quality surf and turf in a stylish setting.
Located at 149 Avenida Messina, this restaurant is known for its fresh seafood, premium steaks, and expertly crafted cocktails.
The menu features standout dishes like Oysters Rockefeller, Lobster Bisque, and the Porterhouse Steak.
The elegant interior, with its high ceilings and tropical fish tank, gives the space a refined yet relaxed feel.
3. Meaney’s Mini Donuts
It’s not a restaurant, but it absolutely deserves a spot on this list.
Meaney’s Mini Donuts is a Siesta Key Village staple serving fresh, made-to-order mini donuts.
This walk-up window at Morton’s Siesta Market keeps things simple—hot, fried donuts and plenty of topping options.
The strawberry cheesecake donut is a fan favorite, combining sweet jam with rich cream cheese frosting.
But the best part? You can customize your own donut creation.
While it’s easy to devour the whole bag in one sitting, be warned—these bite-sized treats are seriously addictive.
4. The Cottage
Tucked away in Siesta Key Village, The Cottage blends tropical vibes with a creative, internationally inspired menu.
This laid-back restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating, often featuring live music to enhance the experience.
The menu is a mix of American and Japanese influences, with standout options like the Grouper Sandwich, Lobster Bisque, and Truffle Fries.
Another highlight is their award-winning Crab Cakes, which are packed with flavor.
5. Sun Garden Cafe
For a relaxed breakfast or lunch, Sun Garden Cafe is a local favorite.
Located at 210 Avenida Madera, this family-friendly eatery offers garden-to-table meals in a cozy outdoor setting.
The umbrella-covered patio adds to its charm, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a fresh and flavorful meal.
Signature dishes include Ashley’s Avocado Toast, Helen’s Biscuits and Wavy Gravy, and a variety of unique Eggs Benedicts.
If you prefer something lighter, try the Flower Child Omelet paired with the Beach Smoothie.
With its generous portions and welcoming atmosphere, Sun Garden Cafe is a must for breakfast lovers.
6. Big Water Fish Market
If you’re a seafood lover, Big Water Fish Market is a must-visit.
This casual dining spot opened on 11/11/11 at 11 a.m., and it has been serving some of the freshest seafood in Siesta Key ever since.
Located at 6639 Midnight Pass Rd, the market specializes in local fish and shellfish.
Customers rave about the Grouper Reuben Sandwich, Hush Puppies, and classic Fish & Chips.
If you’re feeling adventurous, try the Gator Bites or a bowl of their flavorful Fish Stew.
Beyond dining, Big Water Fish Market sells specialty sauces and seasonings, so you can bring the flavors of Siesta Key home with you.
With a laid-back vibe and a focus on fresh seafood, this spot is a great place to grab a meal and a beer after a day at the beach.
7. Village Cafe
For a hearty breakfast or a laid-back lunch, Village Cafe is a Siesta Key staple.
Family-owned since 1995, this cozy café serves generous portions of classic American fare in a relaxed setting.
Located at 5133 Ocean Blvd, it’s best known for its Omelettes, Pancakes, and fresh pastries.
Healthy options like fresh fruit bowls and oatmeal are also available for lighter eaters.
If you’re stopping by for lunch, try the Beyond Burger, quesadillas, or melts.
With both indoor and outdoor seating, this café is a favorite for both locals and visitors looking to fuel up before exploring Siesta Key.
8. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
For a one-of-a-kind ice cream experience, head to Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream.
This shop specializes in flash-frozen, made-to-order ice cream and yogurt, offering a fun and interactive way to enjoy dessert.
As your order is prepared, the liquid nitrogen creates a dramatic foggy mist, making it a hit with both kids and adults.
It’s more than just ice cream—it’s an experience.
One of the top flavors to try is Key Lime Voltage, but if you’re feeling creative, you can customize your own ice cream combination.
9. Big Olaf Creamery
If you’re looking for homemade ice cream in a relaxed setting, Big Olaf Creamery is the place to go.
This small ice cream shop is about six minutes from Siesta Key and is known for its handcrafted flavors and waffle cones.
With purple counters, tiled floors, and a retro vibe, it’s the perfect place for a casual date or a fun outing with the kids.
The laid-back atmosphere makes it easy to take your time and enjoy your favorite scoop.
For a taste of the tropics, try the Coconut Almond Joy flavor.
10. Siesta Key Oyster Bar (SKOB)
A trip to Siesta Key wouldn’t be complete without visiting Siesta Key Oyster Bar, also known as SKOB.
Located at 5238 Ocean Blvd, this lively seafood spot is famous for its Oyster Happy Hour, live music, and vibrant atmosphere.
The menu features fresh oysters, shrimp tacos, and award-winning wings, making it a go-to spot for both locals and tourists.
The bar’s colorful decor and upbeat vibe make it a great place to hang out with friends over a cold beer and fresh seafood.
If you love oysters, don’t miss the Specialty Baked Oysters—the Garlic Parmesan and Buffalo varieties are customer favorites.
If you prefer something fried, go for the House Fried Oysters served with cocktail sauce.
11. Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar
If you’re looking for a true taste of Siesta Key, Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar is the place to go.
Located just four minutes from Siesta Key, this casual seafood restaurant combines delicious seafood with a laid-back tiki bar atmosphere.
Here, the focus is all on the food. Start your meal with the Clamscargot, featuring whole ocean clams in rich garlic butter.
For your main course, the Cajun Combo is a must-try—shrimp and Pollock seasoned with bold Cajun spices.
The no-fuss, relaxed vibe makes this a great spot to enjoy local flavors while unwinding with a cold drink.
12. Miguel’s
For a fine dining experience with a touch of French elegance, Miguel’s is a top choice.
Located at 6631 Midnight Pass Rd, this upscale restaurant specializes in French and continental cuisine.
Each entrée comes with a tossed green salad, vegetable du jour, fresh garlic bread, and potato du jour, making every meal feel like a full-course experience.
Guests rave about the Supreme de Poulet Cordon Bleu, a rich and flavorful take on the classic dish.
Seafood lovers can opt for their popular tilapia entrée, cooked to perfection.
Pair your meal with a selection from their extensive wine list or a handcrafted cocktail from the full bar.
The romantic setting, tableside dishes, and signature Caesar salad make Miguel’s one of the best restaurants in Siesta Key for a special night out.
13. The Old Salty Dog
A Siesta Key classic since 1985, The Old Salty Dog is a dog-friendly restaurant with a casual British pub vibe and unbeatable waterfront views.
Found at 5023 Ocean Blvd, this relaxed eatery is perfect for enjoying classic pub fare with a local twist.
The batter-dipped hot dogs, known as “The Salt Dog,” are legendary and even earned a feature on Man vs. Food.
If you’re craving seafood, the coconut shrimp, fish & chips, and peel-and-eat shrimp are all great choices.
With outdoor seating that welcomes dogs, live music, and a laid-back atmosphere, this spot is a local favorite for both humans and their furry companions.
14. Flavio’s Brick Oven Pizza
If you’re in the mood for authentic Italian pizza, Flavio’s Brick Oven Pizza is one of the best spots in Siesta Key.
Just six minutes from the island, this bar and restaurant is known for its wood-fired pizzas and excellent wine selection.
Flavio’s strikes the perfect balance between elegance and casual dining, making it an ideal choice for date nights or a relaxed dinner with friends.
For a light yet flavorful meal, pair the Pizza Burrata with the Insalata Della Casa.
The rich flavors and crisp brick-oven crust make every bite worth savoring.
15. Bonjour French Café & Crepes
Few places capture the charm of a French-inspired breakfast like Bonjour French Café & Crepes.
Located six minutes from Siesta Key, this quaint café is a favorite for those looking to start their day with a light and flavorful meal.
The outdoor seating offers a bright and airy atmosphere, perfect for sipping coffee and indulging in something sweet or savory.
If you’re in the mood for something classic, the Fruity Crepe is a refreshing option.
For a more filling breakfast, try the Salmon Avocado Toast, served with a side of mixed greens.
With its cozy European vibe and freshly made dishes, this café is a must-visit for brunch lovers.
16. Lobster Pot Siesta Key
Since 1940, The Lobster Pot has been serving fresh seafood with recipes passed down through generations.
Originally from Cape Cod, this family-friendly restaurant blends Portuguese, New England, and Florida coastal flavors into one unforgettable dining experience.
Their live lobsters come straight from Bar Harbor in Boothbay, Maine, ensuring the highest quality.
For a classic taste of New England, try the Maine Lobster Tail or the Portuguese Kale Soup.
Not a fan of lobster? No problem.
The menu also features fish sandwiches, sea rolls, crab cakes, pulled pork tacos, and the fresh catch of the day.
17. Pizza N’ Brew
If you’re craving New York-style pizza, Pizza N’ Brew delivers.
This casual eatery offers hand-tossed slices, specialty pies, and a build-your-own option with a variety of toppings.
For something unique, try the Mediterranean Pizza, topped with artichokes, olives, and fresh herbs. If you’re more into the classics, go for a stromboli, calzone, or a burger.
Want something quick to snack on? Their garlic cheese bread, jalapeño poppers, and mozzarella sticks are perfect for sharing.
Beyond the food, Pizza N’ Brew offers a full liquor bar and a great draft selection, making it a solid choice for a relaxed night out.
18. Ophelia’s on the Bay
Few places in Siesta Key offer the stunning waterfront dining experience that Ophelia’s on the Bay does.
Located at 9105 Midnight Pass Road, this fine dining spot is known for its globally inspired, daily rotating seafood menu made with fresh, seasonal ingredients.
The glass-walled dining area and open-air dockside patio provide breathtaking views of Little Sarasota Bay, making it one of the most romantic restaurants in Siesta Key.
Guests can start with Eggplant Crepes or the Colossal Lump Blue Crab Cakes, both made with fresh, local ingredients.
Pair your meal with a drink from their happy hour menu, available from 5-6 PM nightly.
19. Turtle Beach Grill
Located right across from Turtle Beach, Turtle Beach Grill is perfect for a laid-back meal after a day on the water.
With open-air dining, a dog-friendly atmosphere, and boat access, this casual spot captures the essence of Siesta Key’s beach culture.
Guests can grab boneless wings, spicy shrimp, or fresh crab cakes to start.
For something light, their sandwiches and wraps are great beach-day meals.
But no visit is complete without dessert—the Key Lime Pie is a must-try.
The drink menu is just as good as the food. Signature frozen cocktails, like the Strawberry Colada, are a refreshing way to cool down.
If you’re looking for a fun, beachside bar with live entertainment and tropical vibes, Turtle Beach Grill is the place to be.
20. Cafe Gabbiano
For an authentic Italian dining experience, Cafe Gabbiano is a hidden gem.
Located at 5104 Ocean Blvd, this rustic-elegant eatery combines classic Italian flavors with a casual, welcoming atmosphere.
The interior features dark wood decor, vintage wine bottles, and a climate-controlled patio, setting the perfect ambiance.
A certified sommelier curates the restaurant’s impressive wine list, making it a dream destination for wine lovers.
The menu includes handmade ravioli, rich lasagna, tender veal chops, and perfectly crisp chicken parmigiana.
Seafood lovers will enjoy dishes like Lobster Ravioli or Squid Ink Shrimp Diavolo.
With its cozy setting and authentic Italian flavors, Cafe Gabbiano is a must-visit for a romantic dinner or a relaxing night out.
21. Daiquiri Deck
Food, drinks, and live entertainment—what more could you ask for?
Daiquiri Deck is one of the top party spots in Siesta Key, serving up legendary happy hours, strong frozen cocktails, and crowd-pleasing bar bites.
Start your meal with gator bites, conch fritters, or a massive plate of nachos, perfect for sharing.
For something heartier, the Crab Cake BLT is a local favorite, offering a mix of crisp bacon, fresh lettuce, and a perfectly seared crab cake.
Happy hour runs daily from 3 PM to 7 PM, featuring half-priced souvenir cups, daiquiris, well drinks, wines, and draft beers.
The party doesn’t stop there—weekends bring in DJs, and the restaurant hosts community-wide events like the Turkey Trot and Santa Stumble pub crawl.
If you’re looking for a fun and lively atmosphere, this is one of the best places to eat in Siesta Key.
22. Cha Cha Coconuts
For a Caribbean-inspired dining experience, head to Cha Cha Coconuts.
The menu features coconut shrimp, fish tacos, and half-pound burgers, all served in a colorful, laid-back setting.
If you’re dining with kids, there’s a children’s menu available, making it a great family-friendly option.
Beyond the main dishes, the menu also includes peel-and-eat shrimp, black bean chili, and smothered chicken sandwiches.
While they don’t serve breakfast, their brunch selections and lighter portions make for a satisfying mid-morning meal.
Be sure to soak in the island-style décor, filled with fun coconut-themed decorations.
23. Turtles on Little Sarasota Bay
If you’re searching for a waterfront restaurant with casual dining and beautiful views, Turtles on Little Sarasota Bay is a great pick.
With 36 years in business, this spot has become a staple for both locals and visitors.
The all-day menu includes sweet and spicy shrimp, stuffed mushrooms, and the popular Salmon BLT.
On Sundays, their brunch menu shines with options like poached eggs with corned beef hash, omelets, and avocado toast.
No trip here is complete without a drink from their extensive cocktail menu, which features Painkillers, margaritas, rum runners, mules, and classic Bloody Marys.
24. Another Broken Egg Cafe
For a classic Southern-inspired breakfast, Another Broken Egg Cafe is the place to go.
Located at 140 Avenida Messina, this spot offers indoor and outdoor seating with a large covered patio—perfect for a laid-back morning meal.
Signature dishes include the Bourbon Street Pancakes, Smoked Salmon Benedict, and a variety of omelets and scramblers.
If you’re in the mood for brunch, be sure to pair your meal with a house-made Bloody Mary or one of their six handcrafted mimosa flavors.
Another Broken Egg Cafe is also known for its large gluten-free menu, making it a great choice for those with dietary restrictions.
25. Island House Tap & Grill
If you’re after a casual hangout with great food and a solid beer selection, Island House Tap & Grill is the spot.
Located at 5110 Ocean Boulevard, this restaurant features live music, a scratch kitchen menu, and outdoor seating.
The menu highlights Island House Bowls and Tacos, offering fresh, Latin-inspired flavors.
Try the Tuna Tacos or Grouper Tacos, both local favorites.
And if you have room for dessert, don’t miss their famous Key Lime Cheesecake—it’s a must-try.
With a variety of craft beers on tap and unique canned options, this place is a laid-back, no-frills choice for lunch or dinner.
26. Spearfish Grille
If you’re looking for fresh, local seafood, Spearfish Grille is the place to be.
Located at 1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, this casual waterfront spot is known for its Hogfish dishes, a local favorite that’s hard to find elsewhere.
The Hogfish Taco and Hogfish Sandwich are the stars of the menu, offering light, flaky fish with bold flavors.
Pair your meal with one of their local beers on tap, and don’t forget to finish off with a slice of Key Lime Pie.
With its laid-back setting and focus on high-quality seafood, Spearfish Grille is a hidden gem for those who love fresh flavors and a relaxed atmosphere.
27. Ripfire Pizza & BBQ
At Ripfire Pizza & BBQ, you don’t have to choose between wood-fired pizza and smoky barbecue—you can have both.
Located at 5218 Ocean Blvd, this spot brings together classic pizza-making techniques with bold BBQ flavors.
The Pulled Pork Pizza and BBQ Chicken Pizza are top choices, combining slow-cooked meats with crispy, wood-fired crusts.
If you’re craving something sweet, their dessert pizzas add a fun twist to the menu.
With craft beers on tap and a casual vibe, Ripfire is a great spot for anyone looking for a comfort food fix with a smoky, wood-fired touch.
28. The Hub Baja Grill
Bringing Mexican coastline flavors to Siesta Key, The Hub Baja Grill is a lively restaurant located at 5148 Ocean Blvd.
Known for its outdoor seating and energetic atmosphere, this spot is perfect for enjoying tropical flavors in a fun setting.
Two must-try dishes here are the Grouper Tacos and the Seafood Tower, both packed with fresh ingredients and bold seasoning.
29. Gilligan’s Island Bar & Grill
For a Caribbean-inspired beach bar experience, head to Gilligan’s Island Bar & Grill at 5253 Ocean Blvd.
This spot is all about good vibes, great drinks, and fresh seafood.
The menu features Fish Sandwiches, perfect for a casual bite while soaking in the relaxed atmosphere.
Pair your meal with one of their Rum Runner cocktails, and you’ll feel like you’ve been transported to a tropical island.
With its friendly service and laid-back ambiance, Gilligan’s is an ideal stop for a drink, a bite to eat, and a true taste of Siesta Key’s easygoing lifestyle.
